The tarrasque was restrained. It cannot fully be killed through normal means; therefore, anyone lucky enough to … In any case, I think this is a situation where it's best for the DM to just eyeball what outcome is least stupid/most interesting. Open .laz point clouds not available in QGIS 3.18. Use MathJax to format equations. So our expectation is the rod takes its idea of "doesn't move" relative to the planet (or plane) it is sitting on. On a bad roll, the Rod goes out of control as before, but the party at least understands why their plan didn't work. Thanks for contributing an answer to Role-playing Games Stack Exchange! Please help! More weight causes the rod to deactivate and fall. From the Introduction: Once upon a time, a nation decided to end the threat of the Tarrasque once and for all. Why did the Soviet Union out-pace the US the space-race? What you actually want to use is the mass of the rod, which is about 7 orders of magnitude smaller. The Rogue intends to bar the train door, so that's what the rod does. The party is trying to find creative solutions to problems, and as the DM, we want to reward them for doing that. @Sean One solution to the paradox is that the rod attaches itself to its reference by an invisible force field, force on the rod is transferred to the reference, if a rod attached to a locomotive impacted a rod attached to the ground they would take damage as per impact with a locomotive, and assuming they survived that the locomotive would be suddenly stopped. You can use an action to press the button, which causes the rod to become magically fixed in place. Role-playing Games Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for gamemasters and players of tabletop, paper-and-pencil role-playing games. Reminder: comments aren't for chatting. suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive/1709686, Visual design changes to the review queues. Per the rules, I think the Rod isn't moving and the train is. There was an amusing thread on 4chan's /tg/ about the ramifications of being able to specify the reference frame of an Immovable Rod's immovability about seven years ago. The challenge is then in acquiring, moving, and planting the explosive, not in rolling the right number to see whether it works or not when it's detonated. Is someone else's surgery a legally permitted reason for international travel from the UK? Immovable Rod. Tarrasque vs level 11 party! This flat iron rod has a button on one end. The situation was meant to be solved in any number of ways, so I was trying to evaluate if their first idea was even a viable option. That was sort of the gist of our conversation so far, that is takes time for the magic to kick in as a possible explanation, which I can buy although in your example I think drinking a healing potion wouldn't be quite the same thing. A crash bar (also known as a panic exit device, panic bar, or push bar) is a type of door opening mechanism which allows users to open a door by pushing a bar. It is currently being kept by Yussa Errenis in his mage tower in Nicodranas. This massive shield is used frequently in organized armies for its effectiveness at protecting soldiers and aiding in the formation of lines. Wouldn't setting the frame of reference at the time of creation make the rod start behaving strangely if, on a spherical planet, it moved more than a few miles from its creation site? The Pick: Novak Djokovic vs. Daniil Medvedev, Australian Open Final Betting against Djokovic on Rod Laver Arena is a lot like betting against Tom Brady in the Super Bowl. can be an answer, I do not feel that it applies in this case. This flat iron rod has a button on one end. A 1 kg rod at 60 km/h has kinetic energy of 139 Joules. A) It doesn't change, the device remains immobile relative to the frame of reference it was activated in until it is deactivated or the frame of reference no longer exists (destroyed/other). Conclusion: assuming the rod is stationary relative to ground and not the train, the rod will deactivate if it hits a solid steel wall. An unstoppable force seems like an imperious force, presumably more forceful than earthquakes and hurricanes (that alter the geology of our massive planet), regardless of the mass or size of the object that in its … What are the physical dimensions of the Immovable Rod? Curiosity and Perseverance landing - with so much dust blown everywhere, what's the point of the skycrane? So what happens when you activate it on a train is the same as what happens when you activate it while strolling along: it stops, and obstructs anything and everything that isn't also stopping with it, possibly causing damage. Like Euclid's parallel postulate, the "correct" ruling cannot be derived from prior knowledge. after sustaining heavy damage. site design / logo © 2021 Stack Exchange Inc; user contributions licensed under cc by-sa. the Prime Material). I do not use modern chemistry. The Rod can also be moved slowly on purpose, by a strong creature: A creature can use an action to make a DC 30 Strength check, moving the fixed rod up to 10 feet on a success. That sounds like less that 8,000 lbs of force? DMG p175. Enclosed and mostly Encloses things, like Trains and Wagons and Ships, redefine stationary within themselves. What is the relative return point (i.e. Rod cross-section sideways (let's assume a cylindrical rod, which deforms the pushed steel/iron/wood somewhat) 5cm diameter * 40cm length * 0.5 contact factor = 200 mm^2. Brewmaster. 1 Description 2 Uses 3 The Folding Halls of Halas 4 History 4.1 Pre … Tell the rogue: "Ordinarily, the rod would align to the reference frame of the ground. It is against the nature of an Immovable Rod to behave like a projectile, so it will never do that, even if activated on a moving train. If so, then presumably the Rod works relative to "the ground", i.e. @GMJoe In Aristotelian Physics, there are two kinds of motion: This appears to be a comment on an earlier answer, and would likely be better as such. Metamagic Rods. When the button is pushed (a move action), the rod does not move from where it is, even if staying in place defies gravity. Clearly that can't be sensibly gained from the normative description of its function, so it must have a fixed reference frame. A creature can use an action to make a DC 30 Strength check, moving the fixed rod up to 10 feet on a success. This ruling is chaotic, but can be a lot of fun if the players don't take the game too seriously and aren't too attached to their characters. Does an internal Wall of Force limit the Tarrasque? Same situation but now you running north as fast as you can. Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. Op-amp voltage follower not working as expected. Rods Immovable Rod Rod, uncommon This flat iron rod has a button on one end. Pull it, push it, try as hard as you like, the rod Without teasing you further with all sorts of philosophical re-definitions, let’s analyze the two entities at hand—t he unstoppable force and an immovable object. A lot of DMs are so averse to running into that 2% that they treat IRs like sticks of dynamite. Class Features All of the following are class features of the wizard. This answer explores implications of allowing a frame of reference smaller than "the world". Therefore, the correct ruling is the one that creates the game that the group wants to play. I think there's a strength check or something to move the rod, so probably it should get moved during this, and the enemies should definitely get a save (probably Dex) to avoid damage/death. Roll20 uses cookies to improve your experience on our site. Why did the Soviet Union out-pace the US the space-race? I am attempting to use DMG rules where possible but my table is open to anything UA or from other books. Bad news all round. You can use an action to press the button, which causes the rod to become magically fixed in place. They wait an hour or two - to be sure the train is far from any city - then, on the boss's signal, they all pull out their weapons. When the button is pushed (a move action), the rod does not move from where it is, even if staying in place defies gravity. Thus, the owner can lift or place the rod wherever they wish, push the button, and let go. Can you add that to your answer? It may not be gospel, but I really, really like your Option 1: as long as its consistent with the imovableness of the rod and doesn't violate an explicit rule, the caster's intent matters. If a creature pushes against an immovable rod, it must make a DC 30 Strength check to move the rod up to 10 feet in a single round. It sounds like you're trying to align it to the reference frame of the train floor instead. The tarrasque was restrained. A miscalculation in the kinetic energy, I believe. Idiom "off the rack" and the definition from dictionaries and the usage in a sentence "off the rack policy". If you are somewhat between the two, only then do things get fuzzy (and unpredictable).". Perjalanan menuju puncak perang adalah perjalanan yang sepi, sepi, dan panjang. By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy. Let’s dive straight into the trap. Add details and clarify the problem by editing this post. Scarab of protection: Mummy lord scarab. rev 2021.2.26.38670, The best answers are voted up and rise to the top, Role-playing Games Stack Exchange works best with JavaScript enabled, Start here for a quick overview of the site, Detailed answers to any questions you might have, Discuss the workings and policies of this site, Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, Learn more about hiring developers or posting ads with us, And welcome to the stack! The monster was lured into a tight canyon and the battle began. Precedent and logic need not apply. qsort: Cast the comparator function itself or the parameters in the body of comparator function? Menara Langit menguji murid-muridnya dengan cara paling keras untuk mempersiapkan mereka untuk perjalanan ini. We think of them as so, but only because that's conceptually easier than thinking about how fast we're going in delicate coordination with all this other stuff nearby that helped accelerate us so much. Rod, minor tier, uncommon: 2 lb. Applied to the train situation, the rod would surely subvert the character's expectation, likely causing substantial collateral damage along the way - while failing to protect the party from danger as intended. But not slain. This ruling tends to create the most genre-appropriate game (for high fantasy), consistent with how magic "just works" in most fiction, and works well for groups that desire a narrative-focused and deeply immersive game. To play it safe, grab a couple dozen rods (they are only 5,000 gp a piece) to skewer and restrain him. Gazebo of Immovable Rods: A discussion about gazebos gets out of hand when the idea of constructing a gazebo out of immovable rods gets involved: D&D, Gazebo, Immovable Rod, Tarrasque: 2009-06-26: 6 : 5030483: Nautical Campaign Setting: Livestream/tg/ comes up with something creative and describes a drowned world to us. If the group is playing 4e or 5e, there is no Use Magic Device skill, so you'd probably have to call for an Arcana check instead. Another word for immovable. The story takes precedence over the mechanics, and the "right" answers to those questions are the ones that make a story I want to tell. Are there any downsides to having a bigger salary rather than a bonus? Based on your first Q/A, if you run really fast and activate the rod, it will either keep moving all by itself and disappear into the sunset, or it will hover above your head, speeding up and slowing down relative to yourself (like an invincible weightless shield). What kind of door are you assuming? Have the roughest sneak up and place it between their shoulder blades with the glue on it. Would it compare its mass to the train, or only to the weight capacity of the surface it contacts? Applied to the train situation, it is clear that barring a door is within the purview of an Immovable Rod. With a strength of 41, the Tarrasque can push at most about 36,000 pounds (max carrying capacity times 5). (Needless to say, the attempt to bar the door with the Rod would not succeed.). The train would be destroyed, derail, and kill everyone on board most likely. Until you or another creature uses an action to push the button again, the rod doesn't move, even if it is defying gravity. What is the "Isle of the Blessed" and why should a girl see it before marriage? Does “a point you choose” include any movable surface? Fantasy Costo (Where All Your Dreams Come True; Got a Deal for You) : Sheet1 You can make make builds to arm wrestle Bane with and spells to break Lolth's legs but there has always been a need to due something truly epic to wipe out a tarrasque and even than it's only temporary. At this A) (Assuming that you don't have to physically touch magic items to activate them -- that's an open question in my book) Now you've got a rod in your pocket that won't come out until you deactivate it or your pocket is destroyed. Immovable Rod; 0 weight A funny metal rod with a button on it. Sovereign glue: Kraken ink, or purple worm guts. How is it possible for a collision to be responsible for Uranus's axial tilt? At terrible cost, the Tarrasque was defeated. And remember that even if the rod is immovable, it can suffer damage and be broken. Can anyone give me a lead on the Lando Calrissian Robe lining, Is wifi power consumption related to password length. Chatty comments deleted. You can use an action to press the button, which causes the rod to become magically fixed in place. (In my opinion, this is the more fun idea because both outcomes are interesting, and they won't know which will occur until they try for it.). While you are holding a tower shield: You have disadvantage on attack rolls. Can a homunculus activate my Immovable Rod? An army was assembled, led by the greatest heroes of the age. 2 years ago. This ruling tends to create an environment where players are challenged to use their own scientific understanding to stretch the limits of the game world to devise clever solutions to problems. Hopefully at least one party member has a drive for self-preservation and would tell them not to do it.